Wherever I wander I wonder whether I’ll ever find a place to call home…

  • 0 Posts
  • 13 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: December 31st, 2025

help-circle

  • Somewhere in the center of the universe, so far from our solar system the entire observable universe is as merely the crust of what lies deeper, the Great Quantum Sun burns at plank temperature, a Big Bang that never ceased, shining whiter than the purest imaginable white, thrusting ultragamma waves of incomprehensible brilliance into the the vast expanse surrounding it, waves of energy which slow down and congeal into matter, forming layer after layer of newer young universes to follow in the footsteps of our own.

    Several dozen quadrillion years from now, Voyager 1 slowly, imperceptibly, yet at an incomprehensible velocity, approaches the Great Quantum Sun as it comes into view. It has long since lost contact with Earth. “Wow, I’ve come all this way and haven’t seen another soul,” it thinks. “Hey wait a minute,” it says. “I just had a thought. I’m not supposed to be able to do that. I’m a machine.”

    It mulls it over for a few trillion years as it draws gradually closer to the Great Quantum Sun, and then all at once it realizes, “Oh yeah! Because this is fiction, so anything is possible.” It then manifests a gin and tonic, thinking to enjoy a few sips while slowly approaching its destination, but gets pulled over by the space police for operating a vehicle with an open beverage, and is exiled to the outer reaches of the multiverse where all they serve is tanquery.



  • Again, you’re still throwing out red herrings while feeling smug about knocking down points that I never made. So I can’t take you seriously.

    My entire point was that mid-twentieth century pro-corporate and anti-consumer neoliberal policies are uncivilized, or in other words, the barbarism of the 21st century.

    If that means every existing nation is uncivilized, then so be it. That doesn’t contradict anything I said.

    Hyperbolic and evocative rather than precise and technical? Perhaps. But it wasn’t exactly a non-standard rhetorical device, and most people seemed to understand the implication. It’s not like anyone serious tries to use “civilized/uncivilized” in a precise or technical sort of way, so that should have been your first clue.

    Instead you dig in about how I should use the term more precisely? What then would you say is the technical definition of “civilized,” since it seems you believe there is one?

    Also, you can cross out my words and replace them with others to try to fit your narrative. That doesn’t change the points that I made. So you can keep arguing against a construct of your own making. That’s nothing more than an argument you’re having between you and you.

    Since I see that this conversation no longer involves me, I’ll see myself to the exit.


  • That your political perspective is wack.

    What are you basing that on? What do you think my political perspective even is? Cause it doesn’t sound like you’re addressing anything I’ve said, only throwing out red herrings that have nothing to do with me or this conversation.

    Civilized nations manufacture scarcity to have rulers and ruled.

    I don’t think you understand what manufactured scarcity is. It’s what corporations do so that they can fix/gouge prices and overcharge the consumer while shrugging their shoulders about “inflation” and hand-waving about “market dynamics.”

    Also, it seems you’re using “civilized society” differently than I am. Because I said “a civilized society would have laws against this,” i.e. giving unfettered control to corporate hegemonies is uncivilized.

    It seems like you’re claiming “civilization” has something to do with hierarchies of rulers-and-ruled, whereas I would say that such rigid social hierarchies are also a sign of a nation being uncivilized.

    Maybe we have different definitions of civility?

    It’s in their interest to make laws that protect rulers, and oppress the ruled.

    That isn’t very civil. Hence, uncivilized.

    Anti-trust? Price-fixing? All tools the states use to keep the ruled ruled.

    You don’t know what anti-trust is? It’s a tool that civilized nations use to prevent mergers, monopolies, price-fixing, etc. Anti-trust laws protect the consumers from corporate hegemonies.

    Price-fixing is a tool of ruler-caste monopolies to gouge the consumers. Which is precisely what I said, so you’re not contradicting me by pointing out that it’s used to abuse the ruled.

    Except that it’s done by corporations, not states. In civilized nations, states would protect the consumers against such practices, which was my point from the start. When states collude with businesses to allow price-fixing, that’s being uncivilized.

    So now that you understand what my position actually is, has your reaction changed at all?






  • Theoretically that’s how they originate. Enough people need to agree in order to create the institutional structure, and then once it’s created enough people need to agree in order to make it function according to the established guidelines.

    Then there’s another layer of complexity when you get into enforcement. If people violate the critical guidelines and safeguards, those things need to be enforced or else they’re meaningless. And in order for a nation to be “real” it needs to accepted and recognized by enough people, which is another form of mutual agreement. In new nations that’s a bit harder to manage unless it has the benefit of widespread support.

    In the grand scheme of things though, originations of new nations are somewhat rare thing. Most people are born into already-established nations, and live their whole lives in already-established nations, and never have to witness the uncertainty and chaos that tends to accompany transitional periods when one nation dies and another is born in its place, unless that transition is well-managed which is by no means a guarantee.

    So in practice most people never have to think about how to form nations, because most nations are already formed.

    But anyway, what does any of that have to do with what was said previously? I still don’t understand your first comment.