the grammar being wrong also bothers me

  • dustyData@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    edit-2
    2 days ago

    Here’s my suspicions after all the discussion on this thread:

    The engineers had to change some internal workings for compatibility with PAL, most likely the CMOS sensor clock for the rolling shutter, and for some reason this also forced the camera to reinitialize completely, including the file storage. Thus, rather than implementing a fix, they just let the camera force a card reformat on the user. It seems sloppy because it is. It seems it was just easier to let the camera reformat the storage for every change. It is probably unnecessary for a change between NTSC/PAL modes but it was just easier to just let it be. Since most users will not need to change often, usually you just set the camera to your local mode once and live with it. They definitely didn’t intended for users to flip flop between modes.

    This blob of text:

    • Movies recorded in the [60p 28M(PS)]/[50p 28M(PS)]/[60i 24M(FX)]/[50i 24M(FX)]/[24p 24M(FX)]/[25p 24M(FX)] setting in [Record Setting] are converted by PlayMemories Home in order to create an AVCHD recording disc. This conversion can take a long time. Also, you cannot create a disc in the original image quality. If you want to keep the original image quality, store your movies on a Blu-ray Disc. [p. 78]

    Tells me that there’s some limitations with how files are handled for conversion. Since Blu-ray inherited several historical limitations from the DVD era for compatibility. Including support for NTSC/PAL analog TVs. A lot of this is holdover from a bygone era. The HDMI out port might’ve actually also forced this limitation, since HDMI was still tied to modes back then, for the same compatibility with old ways of processing video signals.

    The MP4 limitation to 4GB files tells me there’s something funky or peculiar about how the camera formats the cards as well. Anyway, only the engineers know for certain why they decided to let things be that way. As I said, it is not rare for sensor and image processor to be lock stepped, it saves on resources and simplifies (usually accelerating) image signal processing. But it does brings about these sort of quirks.

    It seems that if you must record 24fps you have to use NTSC mode. But if you want to synchronize with PAL to avoid flickering lights (only relevant with fluorescent and incandescent lights, or recording screens) you are forced to 25 or 50 fps.