I found a hand plane at the thrift store. I think this is a #4 smoothing plane, which I hope to use for finishing. But before that, it’s quite clear that I’m going to have to clean this up a bit by removing the rust and making it look a bit prettier.
Any advice y’all have for how I might start restoring this?
Been lower than novice in carpentry, I love this man’s videos. He has several Shorts on restoring planes.
https://www.youtube.com/rexkrueger
Here’s a long one, but he has plenty more:
Paul Sellers also has lots of wonderful woodworking content, including restoration of planes.
Paul is a no nonsense man that has generations of experience speaking through him. His style and advice is the best. Put effort where it belongs and get the job done right.
For rust removal - two main options, which one is easier for you depends on your available setup.
- Wire wheel in the grinder, drill press or even chordless drill. Will remove almost everything, is entirely sufficient.
- Citric acid, bicarb or washing soda and water and a drop of dish soap. The ingredients you can get anywhere. See the backyard ballistics channel on yt for recipe or google it out. It will remove all rust without damaging the iron, but will leave a bit dull finish.
I recommended doing whatever you have, and not aiming for perfection, but if you want it as perfect as possible, do 2., then 1.
I’ve restored a few planes of my own and ended up using most of them, but making it perfect is often difficult. Especially if you don’t know how it’s supposed to work and have little/no experience. Even though working principle seems easy, there are very many gotchas that will bite you in the ass. Like, blade, cap, sole, frog - each one plays a very precise role and little changes can throw a wrench in your work in no time. If it’s just for display, just make it shiny.
Get a bucket of evaporust. Nothing safer or easier best rust removing product I have ever used.
Start with a dead-flat surface, like a surface plate or pane of glass, and some high-grit abrasive papers, at least 220. Disassemble everything, including to take the frog out. Run the sole over sandpaper on the flat surface to see if it’s flat; back down to lower grits if it’s really bad. Do the same with the machined surfaces of the frog.
Simple rust removal with a wire wheel, steel wool, naval jelly/Evapo-rust. The flat-sandpaper method is not ideal for removing rust from the lever cap and blade, because they’re flexible enough that pressure distribution can change the metal removal pattern.
Fun fact, which does not alter the advice given here in any way: glass isn’t that flat.
It can vary in thickness and flatness between .0005 and .005 inches.
So like, still the flattest cheapest thing you can buy. It would 100% work in this application. But if you want flat flat. You gotta start grinding. One could, were on so inclined, take two sheets of glass, and rub them together with a dollop of lapping compound between them until a rubbing fluid test shows no high spots.
Then you take a third pane of glass, and give it the same treatment with the other two.
Once you’ve done this enough, you’ll have three of the flattest pieces of material a person can have in the home shop, and just about as flat as anything you’d get in a scientific setting. And you’ll only have a handful of cuts and calluses, and the insanity you suffer will be very mild.
Will it be worth it? No. Will it be fun? No. Will anyone at the party care? Turns out also no.
Anyway yeah a piece of glass would work great
Yeah sometimes it doesn’t matter the effort put in many times on tedius tasks like this is not worth it… you can chose. Buy something already flat/flat enough. Granite counter top. Or just accept the few thou out of tolerance. I hate to say it. a tool is meant to work with not work on. As I get further into my trades career, that plane is scrap. I’d have better luck buying a cheap box store plane and taking the knife to a sharpener to get a proper edge on it.
I find that frequently, guys who don’t do a lot of hands on work find some joy in the ritual of doing anything with their hands. So refurbishing an old hand plane is as good a task as any.
The goal is the task, not the result.
Rex Krueger on YT has some good videos on bringing it back to service.
the first step is taking it apart and cleaning it. He recommends 3-in-1 to loosen things that should move and and don’t, just a dab and letting it soak.
From there a wire wheel knocks off the rust, and a brush and TLC cleans the rest.
From there depends on what you find.
As a side note, my grandma has been downsizing and I’ve been making out like a bandit from tools that probably were my great-grampa’s.
Like this thing:



I brand info. The board it’s on is old, dense and dry, with a pocket cut out for the iron. The frog/tote is bolted on top like a strap hinge.
Restoring these things is a dangerous hobby.
I restored one, which was really just cleaning and sharpening it, but then people kept giving them to me and now I have a cupboard full of spider infested jointers, bench planes, and hand planes.
This one looks like it’s in great shape. Take it apart, give all the pieces a good cleaning, and then sharpen or file out anything that’s super janky.
I do not have good advice for rust removal, do you have a pic of the bottom?
My dad used to have a real kick for restoring old planes after fixing up his dad’s ridiculously old one and getting addicted. I went through a time of desperately trying to find a use for a plane so he could happily give me one, but sadly nothing turned up.
Now he’s over his plane addiction and my doors are crooked af. Ah, fate.
Looks like a Handyman, they have their issues and can be more frustrating than anything. Still I think they are somewhat useful, if for nothing else, practice on setting up a plane.
There are lots of videos on restoring and setting these up, do what you can with it and keep your eye out for a Bailey.



