• 0 Posts
  • 19 Comments
Joined 1 month ago
cake
Cake day: October 19th, 2026

help-circle
  • What are you are basically saying here, is that LLMs are functionally equivalent to intelligent systems but are not themselves intelligent. Most people will not find this satisfying because intelligence is defined in functional terms. Is something is flexible enough to solve a wide range of problems with human or above-human level accuracy then it is intelligent. Whether or not the system is a program, a human or an animal or some slime mold, or a bunch of statistics that system fits the functional criterion of an intelligent system.

    That said, you don’t need to go so far as to ascribe nonfunctional mental characteristics to these systems. These are mental characteristics that cannot be described in functional terms, like eg pain or emotions; you can mimic pain or emotions (which is a functional behaviour) without actually feeling them (the intrinsic, nonfunctional part).

    All I’m saying here is that LLMs fit the functional criterion of an intelligent system, which is the only criterion of intelligence we actually have.

    Does that make sense?



  • Some of the awards here are up to 1 million dollars. Sure an AI company could afford that. And maybe they could give someone enough money that they wouldn’t care about the prestige of discovering these proofs. Given what I know about academia I don’t think that’s likely but it’s conceivable.

    But that doesn’t address the sheer volume of proofs. I’ll just copy and paste what I wrote about this in my above comment:

    This is an interesting story but like I said the sheer volume of these proofs is astonishing. If it was just that one particular proof then you’re above link would definitely be reason for skepticism but we’re talking about nearly 300 proofs here, all dumped at once. Many of them have been open problems for decades if not a century plus, and many of them are so significant that even solving one would have been math news of the decade. A scenario where all these breakthroughs just so happen to be made simultaneously, just in time for OpenAI to steal them is just not believable. That many significant breakthroughs coincidentally happening all at once is unprecedented in intellectual history. I understand that people hate AI, but the fact that people are denying that these breakthroughs in AI actually happened just shows that the Lemmy/Piefed users have, in general, a very minimal understanding of the relevant mathematical literature. You guys can downvote me all you want for saying that but that’s the truth.

    I’m ending this conversation here because it’s not worth my time.






  • This is an interesting story but like I said the sheer volume of these proofs is astonishing. If it was just that one particular proof then you’re above link would definitely be reason for skepticism but we’re talking about nearly 300 proofs here, all dumped at once. Many of them have been open problems for decades if not a century plus, and many of them are so significant that even solving one would have been math news of the decade. A scenario where all these breakthroughs just so happen to be made simultaneously, just in time for OpenAI to steal them is just not believable. That many significant breakthroughs coincidentally happening all at once is unprecedented in intellectual history. I understand that people hate AI, but the fact that people are denying that these breakthroughs in AI actually happened just shows that the Lemmy/Piefed users have, in general, a very minimal understanding of the relevant mathematical literature. You guys can downvote me all you want for saying that but that’s the truth.