• 0 Posts
  • 4 Comments
Joined 3 months ago
cake
Cake day: August 10th, 2026

help-circle
  • You wouldn’t really say someone whose job is represent the company is “toeing the line”, you’d say they’re upholding the company line or dispensing company lines. In the latter case the line is not a boundary but a saying.

    A person who could be seen as violating some established limit is toeing the line. They are putting their toes up to or even over the line.

    A person could be dragging the line, they’d be performing rote, necessary labor, not really carefully representing what the company thinks. In that case the line is a physical connector between two points.


  • Since speaking directly to the proposed change didn’t do much, here’s an alternative to “banning ai slop”:

    Ban the thing that’s happening. If there are too many “low effort” posts, ban low effort posting. If there are too many posts about non open source packages, ban posting about non open source software. If you really don’t want people self promoting with open source (a thing they’ve been doing for decades!) then ban self promotion.

    The problem with all the things I just suggested is that they require serious consideration on the part of a moderator. “Is this post too low effort?”, “is this person promoting themselves in a way the community doesnt want?” and “is this post even about open source?” Are questions that require moderator effort. “Was the repo signed by Claude?” Takes no effort to answer.

    Of course kicking kids out of the sandbox for not playing right kind of defeats the purpose of a sandbox and placing unnecessarily high barriers to entry on the commons defeats the purpose of a commons but what the hell do I know…


  • Because someone will just make c/realopensource and more people will post there than here.

    You’re describing a situation where fewer people adopt ai tools for programming or the adoption rate stays the same. That seems unrealistic. I guess you could also be describing a situation where lots of lemmy users start programming and avoid this community because of its ai ban. That seems like it would be bad though, surely you don’t want a bad thing to happen…

    Basing the path of a community on what will be tolerated or even boosted by its most vocal members is not necessarily the best choice.

    A better path is probably to make a dedicated hand coding community and use that instead of hijacking the extant open source community.