• 0 Posts
  • 4 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: October 4th, 2023

help-circle
  • You think Joaquin Phoenix’s Joker had much in common with the original comic Joker? There’s a million different versions of the Joker, and in some of them he does renounce his actions, LOL.

    The comics have done everything. Making any comparison to the comics is moot because you can find an issue of any character in which they behave differently to their established archetype. Those exceptions do not disprove the rule. On Joker 1 specifically, many creative choices were made, and I think you’ll find, that received a lot of praise. However, and this is key, the core moral foundations were retained: nihilism, mental disorders, the juxtaposition of hysterical laughter in the face of great pain, criminality, etc. This is “modernising” done correctly. How compare against Joker 2. They tore down most of the core archetypical tropes of the character. The character is no longer the Joker. They are some character that some writer made up for some story no one cares about, and the movie was rightly lambasted.

    I not only agree that we cannot control how audiences feel about characters over time, but I think that’s how art should be. There are mountains of books written on the death of the author. Analysing characters and tropes over time with new moral and social frameworks is fascinating.

    On Brosnan and Craig’s Bond, they were well received (begrudgingly or otherwise) precisely because they retained the core character and story archetypes. Maybe they drank beer, or used different gadgets, or made different jokes, or became sad when a loved one died, but they were still Bond. I don’t recall any notable reviews of Quantum of Solace claiming that the reason the movie failed is because Bond was too masculine, or too much like James Bond. Rather, the editing was choppy, the screenplay weak, the characters hollow, and most notably, Bond wasn’t Bond. He lost his sophisticated humour and charm.


  • I think we can find a compromise. Some tastes change, some do not. For example, there are enduring tropes about protagonists struggling to achieve something, experiencing hardship and character development, then succeeding. Or a boy and his dog. Or the arch villain. Etc. The Odyssey uses many of these same tropes. Some dialogue is modernised but the story remains mostly the same.

    The problem is when the core themes or character is discarded. For example, if the Joker became remorseful of his actions and renounced his Joker ways, would he still be the Joker? Or if Luke Skywalker became a disillusioned, pathetic old man who hated the world, would he still be Luke Skywalker? Or if Galadriel, the 5,000 year old elven warrior, highly regarded for her wisdom, was deceived by and got a schoolgirl crush on Sauron, would she still be Galadriel? All of these are examples of writers “improving” the stories “for modern audiences.” They fundamentally altered the characters and stories.

    Want to make James Bond drink beer instead of a martini? Go for it. Want to make James Bond sit around in a healing circle, talk about his feelings, and embrace pacifism? Sorry, but that’s not going to be embraced by audiences.