In the wake of the Proton controversy, I’ve been looking towards alternatives towards their services. Unfortunately, I can’t seem to find a good alternative to ProtonVPN. I’m looking for the following in a VPN service:

  • Port forwarding support
  • Open source
  • Android app and Firefox extension available
  • Relatively cheap, around $3-4 month (okay with annual pricing)

The only options I found were Private Internet Access and Windscribe, but I found issues with them. If I’m cutting ties with Proton based on ideals I disagree with, I should be rejecting alternatives on the same basis.

Based on what I saw in the PIA subreddit, Private Internet Access seems to have some issues with service reliability and concerns about its ownership having ties to Israel, implying Zionist affiliation. Windscribe seems to have better service, but they have had a questionable social media history: edgy marketing including an AI-generated Hitler and a controversy where, according to them, they joked about a guy being mentally ill but their post easily looked like they were saying trans people are mentally ill.

Is there an option I missed? Should I try one of these options despite their faults? I’d like to know your thoughts.

  • hirihit640@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    12 days ago

    If you are using 9.9.9.9 as a DoH provider, then afaik you wouldn’t be using Cloudflare DoH anymore. Cloudflare isn’t an https proxy for DoH. Cloudflare handles the DoH directly.

    • iopq@lemmy.worldM
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      12 days ago

      I had them confused, CF is the target, not the proxy. The proxy would be another server, like SURF

      You can use your ISP’s IP for DNS and the Oracle proxy for the requests.

      SURF sees CF ODoH request for example.com

      CF sees an encrypted DoH request to SURF from your ISP’s address

      example.com sees a request from Oracle

      Oracle sees a request to the IP of example.com and encrypted packets from the ISP IP

      Cloudflare (now as host) gets a request from Oracle’s IP with ECH SNI pointing to example.com

      Nobody actually knows you went to example.com and not some other cloudflare site

      • hirihit640@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        11 days ago

        Based on my understanding of DoH and ODoH this doesn’t sound right at all.

        CF is a DoH provider. They receive DNS requests wrapped in HTTPS, they unwrap it and then resolve the DNS request, and send the response back wrapped in an HTTPS response. There are no other parties necessary. No ISP, no SURF, no Oracle. Besides, since CF unwraps the HTTPS request, CF already knows everything about the DNS request. Adding more parties just means more people know about the request.

        You can optionally add a proxy between you and the DoH provider (in this case CF). This is ODoH. This proxy can be an Oracle VPS. So in total there’s three parties: you -> Oracle -> CF. If Oracle and CF sell data to Google, then the DNS request gets tied back to you.

        If you have some resource explaining the packet flow that you are talking about, please link it.

        • iopq@lemmy.worldM
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          10 days ago

          I would use surf in this example for the proxy in ODoH, so that Oracle wouldn’t see my queries. That way Oracle just sees the IP address from my ISP connecting to the server and connections to some random CF IP. It doesn’t know the domain name I’m connecting to.

          • hirihit640@sh.itjust.works
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            10 days ago

            It’s not clear what you’re talking about. Are you saying you use Surf + Cloudflare for your DNS traffic and Oracle for your non-DNS traffic? What the exact path that your packets are following?

              • hirihit640@sh.itjust.works
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                0
                ·
                10 days ago

                So it’s the same thing then. You now have to trust that SURF is not selling data to Google. I’ve never heard of SURF before, they haven’t built a reputation in the privacy community, what reason is there to trust them.

                And since you’re using Oracle as a VPN for your web traffic, Oracle still knows all the websites you’re visiting. Oracle may not see your DNS requests, but they still see the IP addresses that your web traffic is going to. It isn’t hard to do WHOIS or reverse DNS lookup to figure out what websites those are.

                To be honest it sounds like you aren’t that clear on how these technologies work and how they compare to VPNs and Tor. It definitely sounds like you haven’t actually set up ODoH before, and yet you are recommending it. Maybe refrain from giving advice to others until you have more experience.

                • iopq@lemmy.worldM
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  0
                  ·
                  10 days ago

                  Oracle doesn’t know what website I’m visiting. They know the IP

                  Let’s say you see that I connected to the IP 168.107.12.213

                  What does that tell you? I honestly couldn’t find much other than it’s in Korea. Can’t even find the address of the website that’s using it. What can you tell me about this IP?

                  • hirihit640@sh.itjust.works
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    arrow-up
                    0
                    ·
                    edit-2
                    10 days ago

                    A single example doesn’t say much. First off, most major websites can be determined by a whois or reverse dns lookup of their IP. 80% of your browsing history is still a lot of data.

                    However as you’ve noticed, IP addresses don’t always give away the website. The website owner might enabled registrar privacy. However that won’t do much against a big tech company like Google, who can track and maintain mappings between websites and IPs. So if Oracle were to sell your proxy’s traffic data to Google, Google could figure out what websites these IPs were correlated to.

                    This doesn’t always work though. Sometimes multiple websites are behind a CDN like Cloudflare, so the IP is just cloudflare’s IP. This would be harder for Google to analyze, but it’s still information. If Google has other data about the traffic, like timing data and payload sizes, they could guess which Cloudflare website it corresponds to. And even if they couldn’t figure it out in the end, again, 80% of your data is still a lot of data.

                    Edit: also, if you are now making the argument that IP address data does not reveal anything, then you are conceding that Oracle is not trustworthy from a privacy standpoint. In which case, why use an Oracle VPS at all? Why not just make those HTTPS requests from your home IP? All your ISP sees are requests to IP addresses, so according to you that should be fine right?