Male, 40, 250 pounds (120kg) lifting seriously for 10 months. 💪

According to Jeff Nippard, 10 or more sets per week per muscle group is optimal for hypertrophy. Problem is, however, fatigue is multidimensional—local/peripheral (muscle metabolites, calcium handling, connective tissue), central/systemic (CNS, immune, endocrine), axial (spine/hips), and psychological. To add insult to injury, a certain type of prescription medication I take masks fatigue and boosts mesolimbic neurotransmitters (dopamine, norepinephrine) further exacerbating the problem.

As a result, I struggle to do more than 10 working sets per day, even when I split my daily volume into a morning session and afternoon session with 3-5 minute rests between sets. If I do more than this, I begin to fall behind in my personal life. (apparently “executive function” is one of the first victims of collateral damage for training too hard)

I take ice baths regularly in 6C water. I pride myself on mental toughness so it’s not simply a matter of being lazy or cowardice. I’m also totally fine with doing 10 working sets per day because I’ve made more progress than I ever thought possible and if 10 working sets per day is my limit, I’m fine with that. I’m not complaining, just asking out of curiosity in case others here have gone through this and figured out a solution to this mildly annoying problem.

TL;DR: Is “lowering the systemic cost per set” the only viable solution for a lackluster systemic fatigue ceiling? (i.e. incorporating more “greasing the groove” style training that utilizes a high percentage of 1RM coupled with low RPE and high RIR)

  • alliwantsoda@lemmy.worldOP
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    8 days ago

    If you’re 40 and have been lifting for 10 months you probably literally don’t know how hard you can push yourself

    I’ve done a 10-day water fast and the ice baths I do are far more difficult. You come across as someone who has never done an ice bath in your life because you chose to ignore that detail and instead focus only on an irrelevant detail (that I’ve been lifting for 10 months).

    My mental toughness claim rests on my ice bath statement. I also video-record them and take pics of submerged thermometers and use timers so I don’t cheat the duration or intensity data on my ice bath logbook. I never said that lifting for 10 months is the justification for my mental toughness.

    Why worry about minutiae like optimal weekly set range for hypertrophy or your mesolimbic neurotransmitters when you’re a novice lifter? You aren’t eating in a calorie range for optimal hypertrophy no matter what set range you are at. By your own report what you’re doing is working so just keep it simple. Don’t go looking for problems you don’t have.

    I agree with this part of your statement, though.

    • oat@lemmy.zip
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      8 days ago

      You are entirely correct that I’ve never done an ice bath or a water fast and see no reason or benefit to doing either one. Why should we assume either activity translates to strength training in any meaningful sense? Lets assume that your activities represent mental toughness. Does that translate to knowing how hard you can push yourself during a set? Why would it?

      • alliwantsoda@lemmy.worldOP
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        7 days ago

        Lets assume that your activities represent mental toughness. Does that translate to knowing how hard you can push yourself during a set? Why would it?

        I plan to answer this final part of your question as a standalone post that I will share here next week (and reply again to this comment and link you to my OP).

        The “short answer” is probably yes because it allows you to go beyond muscular failure from the perspective of someone with normal intent and normal pacing issues that we all face at the gym. As a 15 second thought experiment, if you have a grueling 15-working-set gym workout and you “go to actual failure” on your first set, how do you know that your brain is not secretly limiting your intent based on the fact you still have 95% of your workout remaining?

        In summary, intent & pacing are 2 things I have spent dozens of hours thinking about this year because it seems that most pop-sci influencers (such as Jeff Nippard) seem to treat the concept of pacing/intent as less interesting and less important than the main hypertrophy concepts (which is true, admittedly) but pacing/intent are the 2 topics to fitness which I find the most interesting. I love asking myself “why did I reach muscular failure”? Could I have tricked my brain into forcing 1 more rep by manipulating my life story temporarily so that my brain believes that my entire life has been leading up to this 1 singular moment?

        • oat@lemmy.zip
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          6 days ago

          Your personal narrative/will power/mental toughness will not allow you to exceed muscular failure by definition. You do you man but I stand by my comment that you’re way over thinking this.

          • alliwantsoda@lemmy.worldOP
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            5 days ago

            I want to apologize for my comments 2 days ago. I am not an argumentative type of person on the internet but I can see how I come across that way (based on reading my 2 replies to you). We agree more than we disagree, but I am just terrible at written communication and I often wake up to read my old comments feeling like I’m gaslighting myself because my terrible word choices poorly reflect my thoughts and beliefs.

            • Muscular failure is the point during an exercise set where the working muscles can no longer generate enough force to complete another repetition in proper form
            • Some hypertrophy influencers call the above definition “technical muscular failure” because they distinguish between good reps in good form with “absolute muscle failure” (which means an arbitrary cutoff for what counts as an acceptable rep or partial rep).

            I believe that the definition of muscular failure by itself is flawed because it arbitrarily chooses to place something in your control to outside your control as explained in my comment that I made 5 months ago (where I copy/pasted a reddit screenshot that explained it better than I ever possibly could).

            Link to my 5-month-old comment:

            In summary, I’m 100% beyond terrible at typing on the internet… 🤦‍♂️

      • alliwantsoda@lemmy.worldOP
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        7 days ago

        You are entirely correct that I’ve never done an ice bath or a water fast and see no reason or benefit to doing either one. Why should we assume either activity translates to strength training in any meaningful sense? Lets assume that your activities represent mental toughness. Does that translate to knowing how hard you can push yourself during a set? Why would it?

        That’s fair – I encourage not just you, but also anyone reading this, to try an ice bath at least once during their lifetime. Fill up their freezer with large water balloons for 3 days. Break off the water balloon and break the ice with a hammer, otherwise the “cooling effect” of the water balloons on the interior of the frozen ice blocks are wasted because only the outer surface is exposed to ambient bath water.

        I only began doing ice baths after listening to many people swear by them and due to my curiosity, I must know whether or not they are over-hyped. Most people do not take adhd meds and therefore the biggest benefit (according to some people) is the week long benefit of something to do with a flooding of neurotransmitters – I’m being intentionally vague because I don’t want to explain it incorrectly.

        But the biggest benefit I see (and is within the top-3 benefits most people agree on) is that it “resets” your brain’s relationship with pain, discomfort, or adversity. That resetting of your brain’s relationship with pain, discomfort, or adversity makes you immediately halfway between the person you used to be and the metaphorical David Goggins:

        I say metaphorical because I don’t know if he’s legit or a con artist because I don’t know him personally. But according to the youtube summary of the final video, ice baths callus your mind as explained below:

        • Callus Your Mind (9:55 - 12:07): Regularly seek out intentional discomfort and do the things you hate. This practice uses neuroplasticity to rewire your brain to stay calm and resilient during chaos.