WARNING: Spoilers ahead…on a story 2.5 millennia old.

Finally got around to watching it this weekend. After the Mt. Everest sized stack of cash it made and all of the glowing reviews, honestly, it was pretty underwhelming.

First thing’s first. The dialogue was AAAAAAAAAWFUL. Seriously? What the hell? It sounded like I was listening to dialogue written by a small team of junior high students. And not the junior high students that take honors English. I was fine with the choice to do American accents, although I would have preferred British accents for a movie like this cuz it just sounds classier. But that wasn’t it. It was the actual words used by the actors to communicate to each other. It was just so dumbed down and sounded so boring and basic. I’m assuming it was a choice made on purpose to maybe connect with as many modern English speakers as possible, but it largely killed the film for me. I was actually kind of shocked how bad the dialogue was in this movie.

Another thing that kind of bothered me, although not nearly to the same degree as the dialogue, was over-acting. I felt like there were some performances that were dialed up a little too much. To the point where it kind of took me out of the film because I felt like I was watching an actor trying to shoot for an oscar a bit too hard. I think the main culprit on this one was Anne Hathaway. Alternatively, I think there was also an issue of under-acting. I’ll get to that below.

Pacing. Despite having 3 hours to tell the story, I kind of felt like some things were skipped over too quickly. Other things that they spent too much time on could have been shortened to allow more time for things I think deserved the time more. Scenes didn’t really punch the way I thought they should. In the book the scene where he comes back after 20 years and his dog is still alive but dies as he touches it and it recognizes him is really impactful, but it was just kind of glossed over in the movie with little to no emotion from Matt Damon. Same with Odysseus finding out Calypso had trapped him on the island for years. Not a lot of emotion there. Actually, I think the only scene Damon really sold was the siren scene. He did the opposite of over-act for most of the movie.

The film looks great. Gotta give it that. The cinematography is solid. And I’m not saying the film was bad (other than the dialogue which was truly awful). I just don’t get the massive hype. Honestly, I still prefer the 90s made for TV version with Armand Assante. I think the dialogue was better. The acting was better. The pacing was better even though it’s almost exactly the same length as this new version. And they did it without the star-studded cast the new film has. Obviously the new version has better special effects, and I do think overall better cinematography. I acknowledge maybe there’s some rose-tinted glasses thing going for me with the 90s version as I grew up with it.

I guess I’d give this new version a B. Just a mid-range B. With a special handwritten in red ink note in the margins that the dialogue is an F.

Ok, crucify me now.

EDIT: You know what, I’d like to add a few things I did like, beyond the cinematography. I liked Odysseus’ monologue about the siren’s song. I liked his monologue about his point of view of his role in the war when he’s talking to his wife. I liked that Athena ended up being a ghost of someone he watched get murdered at Troy (although I do not like Zendaya as an actress).

  • TwodogsFighting@lemdro.id
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 days ago

    If you want to watch the Odyssey, May I reccomend O’ Brother, Where Art Thou, or The Warriors.

    Come out and plaaaaay aaaaaaaay.

  • superduperpirate@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 days ago

    Visually it was great.

    The acting was wooden and underwhelming.

    The sound was poorly mixed, being both too loud and not loud enough.

    That’s 2.5 hours and $10 I’m never getting back.

    • Sharkticon@lemmy.zip
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      10 days ago

      Sums up most Nolan movies for me. Look good but that’s about it. Actually screw that they don’t even look that good, mostly grey and washed out.

    • prole@lemmy.blahaj.zone
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      10 days ago

      The sound was poorly mixed, being both too loud and not loud enough.

      Also known as the Chris Nolan Special

        • Madagaskar_sky@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          10 days ago

          Of a fucking multi-million IMAX theater! I don’t have that kind of gear lying about! Mix the sound for normal people, or even rich people, sound systems! Hell, mix it for non-IMAX theaters! Other movies do it fine, why not his?

          • Coldcell@sh.itjust.works
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            10 days ago

            He’s got some deluded fucking zealotry about the purity of the experience, keeping IMAX standards throughout to the detriment of more casual viewing experiences.

            From the man who makes Batman movies.

            • BurgerBaron@quokk.au
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              2
              ·
              10 days ago

              That’s exactly the problem with this whole movie. His ego takes higher priority over the art.

    • Flames5123@sh.itjust.works
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      10 days ago

      You must have went to a shitty theater if the sound was poorly mixed. In the first dining hall scene, I was so impressed with the talking ALL around me. It sounded like the people behind me were talking.

      The loud bits were very loud, but I felt it was intended because one part is a screaming cyclops and another is a thunderstorm at sea. It’s supposed to be loud. I never heard any spots that weren’t loud enough though.

    • FudgyMcTubbs@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      10 days ago

      $10 to be mildly entertained for 2.5 hours – that’s not bad value. Not as good value as an underwhelming novel that you got from Kobo on megasale, but better value than putt-putt on a simple tourist trap course.

      • superduperpirate@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        9 days ago

        That reminds me of another factor that made it underwhelming: I was seeing a lot of breathless hype about it from friends and in certain places online.

        There wasn’t nearly enough substance there to live up to the hype I’d seen.

        I was expecting something to keep me engrossed start to finish, that I would walk out wanting to see again repeatedly. I was expecting an experience like what I have with most Coen brothers movies, or some of Tarantino’s stuff, or In Bruges, or Hell or High Water.

        Instead, it was about as underwhelming as the Star Wars prequel & sequel trilogies.

        • Hype: 10/10 frontrunner for best movie of the year
        • My experience: 6/10, and one of the most underwhelming movies I’ve this year
  • So, I was going to respond to a comment OP made, but decided to expand on it beyond that context. I think way folks may be missing is what the Odyssey is, and that’s where the comment started j

    As far as that goes, the Odyssy was never realistic. It’s an epic, written long after the events would have happened, as a form of entertainment rather than historiography. It’s supposed to be unrealistic because it’s the equivalent of a graphic novel.

    The characters are meant to be damn near demigods. They’re the distant past heroes, their stories told orally for generations, then written down in a new form. It simply isn’t about realism. If it was, the sirens and the cyclops wouldn’t be there.

    You have to look at Odysseus as captain america, or black panther. Not quite superhuman in the way of someone like Hercules (the Marvel version or the older myths), but peak human capable of feats that would destroy “regular” people to do just once.

    Thus, trying to filter any version of the Odyssey as historical fails. You can’t make a realistic movie of it because it’s never been realistic, nor the Iliad that precedes it. These are stories of gods, men, and those in between.

    Trying to compare it to something like Band of Brothers, where you find a mostly reality grounded story that’s a fictional pastiche set during a historical event, just isn’t giving credit to the source material.

    This needs to be compared to Clash of the Titans.

    The immersion break of “dad” is more about the audience’s expectations of any far past setting using theatrical formality than any unrealistic placement.

    Think about it. If you see your father fall to the ground, grasping his chest, what are you going to scream? Father? Dad? Daddy? Papa? Most people don’t call their parents mother and father unless speaking about them distantly. Even then it isn’t universal.

    The choice in terms of movie values is a difficult one, because Nolan has to be aware that the audience is going to be jarred by their preconceptions when a character supposedly alive over a thousand years ago doesn’t have a British accent, and a posh one at that. But that’s no more realistic than dad. It’s a preconception, not an objective and direct translation of what someone in the time the Odyssey is set in would have said.

    People habe suggested “oh brother where art thou” as a superior version of the Odyssey. I don’t disagree, but I would point directly to the language used in that movie. It’s vernacular English, and not even particularly accurate for the setting it’s in. The accents aren’t realistic, they’re as overblown as a theatrical British one. But we set that aside because the film is amazing in its own rights.

    I’m not saying the Nolan Odyssey is a perfect film. Hell, I even agree that it doesn’t measure up to its hype. But I think OP’s criticisms are as much or more about the preconceptions of the moviegoers as the movie itself. I would agree with the rating of B though! It has flaws (and one of the comments made mentions the jank that’s due to IMAX filming necessities where you can only record so much at once points to the one I notice most in IMAX movies), and it has a very Nolan style. Nolan isn’t really who I would pick to bring the Odyssey to the screen because you do end up with a little too much style creep, but I also think it’s a worthy addition to the litany of greek myth based movies.

    • boonhet@sopuli.xyz
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      9 days ago

      Holy shit a good take on the movie!

      I like recommending the Emily Wilson translation of The Odyssey, which was recommended to me recently and I even went through the translator’s notes. She specifically says The Odyssey was not originally written in a grandiose form, but just rather regular speech for the time and Shakespearean or Victorian or whatever English is just as far from the ancient Greek as modern day English is, so it’s actually better to use common English for the reader’s understanding rather than some just as anachronistic form of the language that’s also stylistically wrong.

      So “dad” is just fine. Telemachus was a teenager. Do we think they did not have anything other than official “I’m addressing the king, I must use only the bestest of words” speech to use in their day to day lives in ancient Greece? I somehow doubt that.

      There are few common men with names in those poems. Most characters that are named, have intimate relationships with gods. Odysseus can kill 108 suitors with a bow and arrow because for decades he’s been making sacrifices to Zeus and Athena and in his current endeavor, Athena herself is aiding both her and Telemachus. But the gods don’t just love him for making sacrifices. They love him BECAUSE he’s strong and (usually) wise and cunning. They most often bless those who have already blessed.

      I’d give it a 7-8 out of 10. Replace Jason Bourne and the stupid ass 70mm film, and it could be much better. I didn’t even mind Spidey as Telemachus, Telemachus HAD to be played by someone who’s believable as a weakling towards the beginning of the movie and grows up (partially at least) to be a proper man. I’m sure they could’ve found someone better, but it’s not nearly as bad as people make it out to be.

  • jbm@lemmy.zip
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    9 days ago

    If I liked Jason and the Argonauts from 1963 will I like this movie?

    I tend to like or dislike movies based on personal taste, irrespective of any technical concepts that someone can learn about in a movie-making class, which all goes over my head. A long time ago, I was friends with actors, and they used to tell me when there was bad acting in a movie. That made me sad in a couple different ways. So maybe my question is impossible to answer, and I just have to watch it to find out.

    But I heard it is 3 hours long. Does anyone know if they plan on releasing a version of the movie that trims it down to around 90 minutes? I miss when adventure movies were 90 minutes long. Oh wait! Turkey Day is almost here, and I can watch long movies then. I think I just found a new Turkey Day movie, if it is like Jason and the Argonauts.

  • Furbag@pawb.social
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    edit-2
    8 days ago

    Tom Holland was super distracting in this film. Idk, I just see him and I don’t see Telemachus, I see Spiderman. He’s too recognizable.

    Zendaya was less bad, but same problem.

    Maybe if they didn’t always cast these two in the same films the comparison wouldn’t be so easy.

    • Blue_Morpho@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      10 days ago

      Maybe if they didn’t always cast these two in the same films

      You mean Spiderman? Because that’s the only other movie series they are in together.

      edit:

      maybe you have Zendaya confused with Mark Walberg?

      • DarkFuture@lemmy.worldOP
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        10 days ago

        Yeah, but there have been FOUR Spiderman movies starring Tom Holland and Zendaya in the last 9 years. So even though it’s just Spiderman, the zone is getting flooded with Tom Holland and Zendaya.

      • AAA@feddit.org
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        edit-2
        10 days ago

        ~~Holland and Zendaya are also main characters in the Dune movies. ~~

    • DarkFuture@lemmy.worldOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      10 days ago

      Yeah, Holland and Zendaya are having that effect where they’re just in too much stuff, specifically together, that it kills the immersion. I’m not a particularly big fan of either actor.