• 0 Posts
  • 4 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 3rd, 2025

help-circle
  • So you’re saying we will no longer be able create and run open source software / hardware

    That is exactly what google is doing with Android in 42 days.

    …turn off / remove TPM

    You can disable TPM, but it would be similar to me installing a custom android ROM on my phone.

    My bank app will know my phone has been modified and that app can disable itself.

    It’s currently the case with Windows 11. You must have TPM enabled to install it. There are ways to circumvent this, but you lose the ability to get windows updates because the attestation/TPM check fails.

    …change operating systems to linux

    Linux will always be an option and running open source apps on it will always be an option.

    … but… concepts like using attestation for age verification is gaining traction.

    This mean you won’t be able to access certain websites unless you pass the attestation check, which means your (Linux) device must conform to whatever specification the company that’s handling the age check. I don’t know what those specifications will be, but I think it’s safe to assume custom compiled kernels will not be allowed (meaning you’ll be limited to commercial vendors Ubuntu/Red Hat/etc) and unsigned kernel modules will not be allowed either (see Kernel Tainting).

    Yes, today age attestation is being pitched to “protect the children from porn”. Tomorrow, it’ll be your bank because “your security is important to them”. Then it will be Amazon and just about any other website because they simply want a 100% reliable way to track you as an individual (“think of the unblockable targeted ads!” /s)

    …or use existing and future DRM removal tools?

    Microsoft (just like google is today) can allow/deny you to install sideload “unsafe applications” like your existing DRM removal tools.

    In the future, however, DRM (as a dedicated mechanism to protect content, thus having dedicated tools to remove it) won’t actually need to exist.

    For you to get any copyrighted content, you’ll need to pass the attestation check, which means that your OS (windows/Linux) must be in a “known state” (ie: free of DRM removal tools, capture cards, sniffers, etc). So effectively your device will be enforcing the digital rights/ownership.

    This also means software like Denuvo (and their negative impact on the performance of games) will be obsolete. …which is really the only ray of sunshine in this whole story.

    edit: a word



  • I admire your optimism, but I’d suggest you take a peek at the concept of attestation.

    In a nutshell, starting with Windows 11, all the pieces are in place for microsoft to turn Windows into the walled garden. It’s the same concept used on iPhones and is being applied to Android.

    The simple explanation of attestation is: it’s possible for any application to validate (via cryptographic signatures) that the application itself, the operating system (re: Windows), and the hardware are all not modified.

    The linchpin is baked within the hardware of your computer as there are some public/private keys (TPM). These private keys will never be exposed and if they are, the OS can simply invalidate them during the next OS Update. The public key can be used by the OS and application to validate that “everything is fine”.

    Tools like WINE and even virtual machines will never get a legitimate TPM key. So they will always fail their attestation checks. (Just like your banking app not running on your rooted or custom android firmware)

    That said, at the moment Microsoft has decades of backwards compatibility shovelled into Windows, which they’re not going to simple drop… and I assume that’s going to make full enforcement of attestation difficult.

    But it’s not if Microsoft will do it, it’s when and this will be a slow boil as older applications and APIs are depreciated in favor of attestation enforceable replacements.

    tl;dr The OPs concerns are legitimate.